Why does this sound familiar?
Why does this sound familiar?
At least in one I have to agree with @dontknow : Steam has no place here preinstalled, nor does this HP-manager. Well, it can be removed without any problems (just like snapd and flatpack), but is that necessary to clean the system after a new installation?) Minimal-ISO is no alternative for me.
People that think alike, talk alike, walk alike, write alike, without knowing what those that put together the ISO’s know.
There where a ton of Printing and Steam related topics in the archived forum for the simple fact that people did not know how to deal with them if they installed them, so, was only reasonable to be included by default. I don’t use any of them either, but i prefer uninstall than to deal with countless topics about them in here.
I’m not aware of any leftovers. Indeed some files/folders for configs remain in the $USER home directory, but we talk about a couple of KB, with no influence whatsoever on how the system continues to perform. If Linux was dealing with registry as Win$ does, then would be another story entirely. But is not the case.
Even MacOS keeps user configs in Library after a software uninstall/removal, unless is done trough appcleaner or similar software.
On the next release, I’m trying to get the hybrid netinstall going. This would let users choose at install time if they want features like
- printer support
- games (steam)
- office suite
- browser (chromium, Firefox etc)
- password manager
Here is a prototype
@Chrysostomus simply a dream, stay tuned!
I think I may have found quite a serious fallacy: zfs is marked as supported on architect, which ships with the 5.6.15 kernel, but there is no linux56-zfs kernel available in the repositories, making it impossible to install a system on zfs
Sorry to make this unrelated post here, but I just can’t work out how to make a new post about how I get no sound on my Philips 32" BDM32U1 connected through a HDMI cable to an ASUS NVIDIA GEFORCE GT 710 video card. I can’t find any other posts in which there is a solution. Are there instructions somewhere which explain to me how to make a new post on a new subject?
Just go to the relevant category and you will see a “big” round red button with a white + at the lower right corner of the screen. At least that’s how it works for me.
Thank you, cfinnberg.
I have since found a big red button and have made the post.
I am not sure why I could not see that red button before.
Which has Firefox, I believe!
Zfs support in manjaro-architect is experimental and may require manual intervention.
Manjaro-architect installer is available in all Manjaro isos, not just manjaro-architect. I actually recommend using it with gui isos, because that is how it is developed (it was originally written for manjaro bspwm edition). I don’t think I have ever done a full installation on the manjaro-architect iso
You mean in live session? The password is simply: manjaro
I agree that the live version should somehow inform about it, but it is the usual Linux custom to have distro name as password when nothing is mentioned.
Kmail is a disaster IMO. There are some people that do like and use it, but in overall, Thunderbird is superior. Manjaro offers good software, not that in theory is the default for given DE. This is not a flaw but a conscious decision. Thunderbird is currently the best open-source client out there and the rest are just toys, good for casual users but not those who work with many mails on a daily basis. I know because I use it for over 10 years and tested many, many other clients, which were massive disappointments. It was like trying out scooter after using Audi. Sure, the UI is a bit ancient, but in the grand scheme functionality is what matters. No amount of modern, cool or good-looking UI can compensate for functional lacks.
To sum up, you just judged distro just based on the fact that you would choose differently. Guess what, every person have different opinion and would choose differently if given the choice. Shouting disappointment just because the choices that Manjaro team did aren’t agreeable with yours is just silly.
On this one I agree, Elisa is the better choice now. I suspect that Manjaro still has Cantata as default comes from the fact that Elisa is a very new software and is good only since few months. Earlier it was rather in a beta state, full of lacks and problems. It still has beta quality in many areas but Elisa development is going fast so Manjaro should reconsider switching to it.
Again, choice was made carefully and the majority of the community will probably agree that Qbittorrent is superior (KTorrent was a default in the past but community feedback probably made the change) and still a Qt app, so it’s better to ship distro with the best app rather than DE default. Kudos for Manjaro team for this kind of approach.
That is again your preference. For me those are OK defaults and I don’t see many users complaining on those.
Didn’t Manjaro implement an office package picker during installation a while ago? Maybe you just missed it and clicked too fast next->next?
I and many others will agree that the welcome screen in Manjaro is bad. There were many discussions about it but it looks like nothing came out of it. I guess, someone has to step up, design and create better one. Remember, that this is a community based distro and current Manjaro devs can’t do everything - they are still doing it in free time, and they have jobs and families. Manjaro was turned to a business project but I doubt it is a profitable one, so this is still labor of love and it won’t be perfect given then limitations. We need more developers jumping on board. Unfortunately, Manjaro is suitable for average users who are power users, but those often aren’t programmers.
This is a standard across other DEs as well. Manjaro is not an exception here. This is a weird attack angle. Following that logic you could find thousands of things that are dissapointment poits. Guess what, we all do those customisations ourselves, becase we want to make the choice, so one will choose uBlock, other will choose NoScript and other add-disabling plugin.
LOL, for years I heard peoplke claiming otherwise, they hated the old windows manager. For most this is one of the very things they do after install, switch to icon task manjager. KDE devs recognized it and made it the default. Manjaro simply keeps this default, because Manjaro users commonly complained about that as well.
For me task icon managers are super convenient and I love them. I can’t understand how people can still use the old ones. They are confusing, crowded and clunky. I would say that the old windows managers are “dumb as hell”…
Opinion vs. opinion. You seem to mistake your opinions with facts.
You fail to recognize that your preference is not what is good for others. I hope you will never be in position to decide things for others (like manager, CEO, etc), because you will be terrible at it. What you think is better and superior is usually not the same for others. For example, I pointed out why Thunderbird is better and it actually is: at least function wise, because it offers more. However, there are many users who don’t need those functions and prefer something simpler, modern. Others will keep love and use Thunderbird for what it can do. You just can’t make everyone happy, because each choice will hit negatively some group. Manjaro usually goes with functionality - usually . It does happen that community chose something I don’t like. Life.
For years it was the desktop that was the default. Community usually didn’t like it, so Manjaro devs improved it. Don’t like it? You can change it, but again Manjaro followed the community will in this point. Or maybe this was change on KDE side and Manjaro simply inherited defaults?
Besides, people expect the same functionality they are used to on Windows and some things Windows does right.
Also, think: if you don’t want to clutter your desktop, Desktop as folder is not keeping you from it. If you won’t put any files on it, it will stay clear. With the Desktop full mode, if someone wants to clutter desktop, they can’t, they must change the option. So your choice would be abrasive for a big group of users, while Desktop as folder is neutral, which is a superior choice.
This is a one of the Manjaro unique features to have Steam installed by default and it’s going to stay. It is usually mentioned as one of the Manjaro perks, because this is unusual. Most popular distros don’t have it.
This is also a statement: We are not open-source exclusive, we offer everything you need and want.
And lately: We are a distro good for gaming.
Again, no matter what kind of software choice Majaro devs did, someone will be unhappy about it. That is why there was in the past Minimal-ISO option. Not sure if it’s still available, but you can still use Manjaro Architect and there you can decide for minimal install.
Official release will keep offering ready to work and game distro and that means some software choice you don’t like. I hate yakuake and there is already Konsole so I always uninstall it. This does’t make distro worse, it simply is some choice that in some points agree with mines, with others does not.
It looks like the release is simply not for you. Use Architect and be happy with semi-Arch like experience, no need to complain on Manjaro dev’s choices.
That’s a mystery for me too. What does it do on Manjaro? HP is one of the worst printer companies. Everyone in family or neighbors have HP printers, and THEY ALL ARE A DISASTER. Because of that I stay away of all things HP. Those printers may be working out of the box in Linux, but aren’t a good choice for anyone.
Anyway, your detailed critique probably comes from the fact that you do care and want to improve distro, but you are going the wrong way about it. Manjaro is not perfect and it indeed needs some improvements. Many of your points are valid IMO, but they aren’t deal breakers or anything to be really disappointed about.
If you became a regular forum user with high trust, offered programmer help and other show that you have knowledge and skills, and then opened topics to discuss things that can be improved (just an on-point talks, without emotion and all that negativity), you could make a positive impact.
Like the new themes - esp Matcha Dark Aliz!!
It’s about compromise and out of the box experience.
@philm wanted all printer stuff gone because everyone does not have printers.
I wanted to include just the drivers, so that everything works out of the box, but users aren’t bothered by the hp app.
Other maintainers wanted to keep the hp interface because it offers extra functionality. So, here we are.
I also have HP printer and it sucks big time. But I’m stuck with it, and it works better on Linux than on windows. Having printers work out of the box without hunting for drivers is awesome. I would still kick the hp printer manager if I could, but it’s not my call.
This is indeed awesome, thanks for supporting printers, I need to print a few times a year and the out of the box support of my seven year old WiFi scanner/printer surprised and delighted me
For the majority of people it is pretty much obsolete indeed, I guess.
The last printer I had died around 12 years ago and it ended with something I’d just call “sledgehammer incident”.
Having an option during installation would be good I think.
Similar to the office suite selection… (Print drivers: No; CUPS basic; HP bloat or so )
@dontknow Well made points. Is there anything else we can help you with? What a wasted effort maybe Manjaro is not your thing? Maybe moved to a more generic distribution that has all the proper applications and system setting etc. My KDE is awesome works without problems! Been using it for many years. It was and is the best rolling release Linux has to offer, hands down! Maybe Windoze would work for you better? What I am saying is just lighten up just a bit and enjoy whatever distribution you like!
This is planned for the next release of gnome edition. @codesardine made a working prototype of hybrid netinstall, which can easily handle this.
A post was split to a new topic: Does Manjaro have systemd?
Love Manjaro XFCE - been a solid user for years now. Thank you.