Again, I’ll preface this by saying I’ve never used Autologin;
However, I would have thought that the user that is allowed to auto-login should be specified. Does not omitting the section completely make any difference?
Reset to default using the ssdm menu (within system settings)
Reboot
Deleted the user manually from the files sddm.conf and kde_settings.conf (as after a reboot I still got an autologin even though the checkbox was not ticked).
Reboot
This time, the autologin section stuck with the sddm.conf file (maybe due to me setting everything back to default?).
I will reboot several times more in the upcoming days, just to make sure it stays that way.