Don’t worry, be happy ![]()
testing or unstable branch is a deliberate choice
Building an AUR package is also a deliberate choice that should not be taken away from stable branch users
If an inexperienced user asked me for help updating repository packages, I would suggest they copy/paste this command to a terminal
pamac update --no-aur
and report back if there are any warnings or errors
Anne Isabella Ritchie
if you give a man a fish he is hungry again in an hour; if you teach him to catch a fish you do him a good turn
Such a choice would be more at home within the Apple ecosystem.
I can appreciate why the stance was likely taken. We have been telling (strongly recommending) for years that AUR users switch to either Unstable (preferable) or Testing due to those branches being the closest to Arch. The warnings typically fall on deaf ears.
The application is doubtless aimed at a narrow demographic, and at face value one could argue the need for… something… Yet, I find myself questioning whether this is that something.
While this project may serve a certain niche, it also removes a fundamental freedom – that of choice – it’s arguably true that giving up a few freedoms can potentially serve the greater good. Whether this is such an example, I can’t say.
The AUR has always been a double-edged sword that can cut both ways; I doubt the argument for or against will be won here,
Agreed.
But perhaps going forward to Manjaro 2.0, a survey of AUR users and apps can inform the choice of things that might be added to the repos.
We have been telling (strongly recommending) for years that AUR users switch to either Unstable (preferable) or Testing due to those branches being the closest to Arch
That does not include myself
If a user has a problem with an out of date package on stable branch they have 2 possible choices:
- switch branches
- wait for stable branch to update
it’s arguably true that giving up a few freedoms can potentially serve the greater good
Tyranny of the majority - Wikipedia
Tyranny of the majority occurs under majority rule when the preferences and interests of the majority dominate the political landscape, potentially sidelining or repressing minority groups and using majority rule to take non-democratic actions
Argumentum ad populum - Wikipedia
argumentum ad populum (Latin for ‘appeal to the people’) is an informal fallacy that asserts a claim is true, good, or correct because many people allegedly think so
In every organized entity the tyranny of the majority is ruling. What is more disturbing is when members of said entity seem guided by the Orwellian motto ;
"All animals are equal, but some animals are more equal than others"
or translated in vulgar for the benefit of those who might not be familiar with Orwell’s opus :
Do as I tell you, not as I do
Which many times becomes Vox populi, used and abused by a big chunk of politicians on both sides of the aisle.
It is really, really simple.
While there can be a lot of arguing that one should make one’s own decisions and review the choices but this app is not about that…
Remember this
- remember where it comes from (Stable GUI updates would make this distro to be one of a kind,)
- remember the definition
- remember the purpose
- remember the target user base
- remember the very narrow scope
So by using the app one accepts that certain decisions is pre-configured including the removal of custom packages if present.
If you cannot accept the choices the app makes, then don’t use the app…
- Don’t bring into the topic all your freedom arguments…
- It is not about freedom or choice…
- It is about ease of use and stability on stable branch…
My testing in a virtual machine using Xfce
- https://download.manjaro.org/xfce/26.1.0/manjaro-xfce-26.1.0-minimal-260812-linux71.iso
- https://download.manjaro.org/xfce/26.1.0/manjaro-xfce-26.1.0-260812-linux71.iso
I added custom packages
google-chromevisual-studio-code-binbrother-hl-l8250cdn
EDIT:
Sources moved to
This sounds like an excellent foundation not only for naive individual users, but also for corporate deployments. In fact, that may turn out to be the largest and most-important use case, with regard to growing the user base.
While it’s not for me (Unstable and Testing branches here, with several AUR packages) I can see it as helping me to recommend Manjaro to new escapees from Windows.