Anyone else getting really bad foreshadowing vibes?
I was under the impression that there is a foundation of sorts that’s maintaining Manjaro, but this remark somewhat implies that it might all depend on one single guy.
Anyone else getting really bad foreshadowing vibes?
I was under the impression that there is a foundation of sorts that’s maintaining Manjaro, but this remark somewhat implies that it might all depend on one single guy.
Well, he is speaking about his response time. That doesn’t mean that everything in Manjaro stops. But it’s true that apparently he is the only one that controls some things.
The foundation is still in the making and Philipp still works on manjaro, even if not so intensive. In fact he is rearranging and updating the server infrastructure right now ( since the weekend. )
The foundation is still in the process of getting legally registered — as you can read here — and this has nothing to do with Philip’s private life or his personal activities.
Besides, there is some heavy restructuring going on behind the scenes that you guys don’t know about — predominantly problems with the server infrastructures for our GitLab instance, the mail server, the Wiki server, and so on. Philip is working on those things, and those of us with knowledge about those infrastructural aspects are trying to help him with that.
Relax, people. Manjaro isn’t going to run away or disappear in a cloud of mystical smoke. ![]()
Is there a reason why this restructuring process you mentioned isn’t being made transparent to the community?
Depends a bit how long will it take and how much the average Joe will be affected at all (so far it should not be the case). If it takes more time than 1-2 days and if it affects any user facing service there will be announcement.
I’d say it’s as transparent as it needs to be, for now. It’s mainly technical details being discussed “behind the scenes”, which probably wouldn’t interest most people. ![]()
Actually Philipp has already written something in the announcement for the stable update:
This post by @philm sheds some light on what seems to be going on internally, that’s the information I was looking for.
It would seem that the foundation is still in the process of being formalized, while key figures like @philm seem to be gradually withdrawing from the project (judging from the quote mentioned in my OP).
Seems like there might be some rocky times ahead.
There are no indications that Philip would be withdrawing from the Manjaro Project. Do not forget that he owns a commercial business centered around the Manjaro GNU/Linux distribution. He cannot simply turn his back on that, and I personally do not think he would.
Besides, if he were to want to withdraw, then he wouldn’t be putting so much effort in trying to solve the problems with the server instances.
What Philip did say, however, is that he will not be involved with the non-profit organization we are creating — for obvious reasons, because that would become a conflict of interest, given that he’s got a commercial company to run.
Or Everything is absolutely normal.
Philm already said that the core team considered to have the entity as non-profit from the very start, but at that time Gmbh may have been better option, because the community was very different and had a lot of developers and contributors.
Regardless, The Project has been as close to the FOSS and Ethical Philosophy as it can be…
So give the team credit for that. They could have taken wild opinionated or super profitable approach and commercialized the distro, but they did not.
In general with Commercial ownership also comes the Legal Responsibility part, if someone’s not part of the commercial entity, there will be hesitation to give access to contributors, as the entity is legally responsible for everything that would go wrong.
There are too many things happening in managements that the general public, or in this case us the community, cannot see clearly.
With the project being this close to Ethical Philosophy and Hardworking staff, I trust everything will go smoothly.
If not… then it’s not gonna disappear overnight or have crazy malware risk from repos.
Relax. Don’t look for spice where it doesnt exist.
You judge this from a quote about time limitations? If you had followed the forum for years you would know that such quotes aren’t unusual. Here is one from long before any manifestos
Now in that case he shared the reason but he doesn’t need to. You can’t always share - little reminder your own profile isn’t set to public ![]()
Anyway, running a distro (even be it only a derivative one) is more work than “communities” realise or care about (they take it simply for granted). It should be obvious that there are time limitations for everyone involved. I would be very surprised if you can’t easily find these in other FOSS projects as well. ![]()
Having used Manjaro exclusively for the last 13 years, I can say with confidence that, a) there have been more challenging times & b) Manjaro isn’t going anywhere. If Manjaro was anything near a one-man show, it would have fallen over long ago. As someone else said, it takes a massive amount of collective effort to keep such a project going, and for that we can all be thankful to the core team, along with those that run testing branches. More power to Manjaro & community!