Block removal of running Kernel from Manjaro Settings

Feedback Feature Request
#1

OK I wanted to initially ask if this was a bug or not, I can’t properly remember, but apparently you can remove the running kernel from Manjaro Settings. I was pretty sure this was grayed out before, but can’t find a way to confirm. So I’m asking here, was it always the case or is it a bug?

If it is a bug then OK this needs to be reported and this thread can be closed.

If it is not a bug I think this is critical to block users from removing the running Kernel in Manjaro Settings application, and ask for this feature to be implemented.

#2

Is another kernel is installed besides the running one you want to remove?

#3

The CLI version mhwd-kernel does not allow removing the running kernel

# mhwd-kernel -r linux511
Error: You can't remove your current kernel.

If you are installing another kernel then you can add rmc

mhwd -i linux510 rmc
#4

For me yes, for someone else no I don’t think so.

So about Manjaro Settings then? Is it normal that you can remove the current Kernel, or not?
Look what I’ve done, what do you think will happen if I remove the remaining kernel now?

1154×859 115 KB

:fearful:

I tried, it works I can remove it, but it actually stops because of virtual box which needs its modules, but let say I don’t have virtual box…

//EDIT: rebooting on unique kernel to test if it still allows me to remove the unique currently running kernel.
//EDIT 2: and I confirm that I can remove the unique currently running kernel, leading me in a situation where I broke my system.

1680×1050 184 KB

1680×1004 124 KB

If I reboot now, it is game over.

#5

And this’ why I’ll always have a kernel installed that I don’t tamper with.

P.S.: Then don’t reboot @omano, you brave man!

#6

Yes YOU know things, but this is not the point :smiley:
The issue here is that it is possible, in the graphical tool, which is more than likely used by noobs, when apparently the command line tool prevents you from doing that. Sure you can decide to not do it, but it is possible.

So the real question here, is it a bug in Manjaro Settings, is it intended (I don’t think so)?

If bug I’ll report it or someone will, if not a bug then I don’t see why it allows it, it shouldn’t in my opinion.

PS: hehe yeah I’m not rebooting, I already reinstalled my kernel I’m not that dumb.

#7

Can see you have a very reliable power supply. Sadly, we don’t. And that’s why I won’t tempt fate like that.

P.S.: I know it’s not the point. It wasn’t supposed to be close to the point. I get, and agree, with the point. I was just mentioning it in passing.

#8

Just checking if someone at Manjaro cares about what seems to me to be an issue, I see I can still remove my currently running kernel in the GUI.

1680×1050 141 KB